Interest-Only Investment Loan vs Principal & Interest: Which Loan Structure Works Best for Property Investors? (2025 Guide)

Choosing the right loan structure can have a huge impact on your investment returns, cash flow, and tax position. In 2025, as interest rates stabilise after several volatile years, Australian investors are again asking the big question:

Should I go with an Interest-Only (IO) investment loan, or Principal & Interest (P&I)?

The answer isn’t one-size-fits-all. It depends on your goals, your time horizon, and your broader financial strategy. This guide breaks down exactly how each structure works, the pros and cons, and what lenders are looking for right now — so you can make an informed decision for your next investment property.

What’s the Difference Between Interest-Only and Principal & Interest Loans?

Let’s start with the basics.

Principal & Interest (P&I) Loans

With a P&I loan, each repayment covers two components:

1. Interest – the cost of borrowing money; and

2. Principal – the amount you owe to the bank.

Over time, you reduce your loan balance, which in turn reduces the interest charged. Most owner-occupiers in Australia choose P&I repayments because they steadily build equity and eventually own the property outright.

Interest-Only (IO) Loans

With an IO loan, you only pay the interest for a set period — usually 1 to 5 years for residential investors, and up to 10 years for some commercial or SMSF loans.

Your repayments are lower during the IO period because you’re not paying down the loan principal. However, once the IO term ends, repayments switch automatically to P&I, which increases the monthly amount unless you refinance or extend the IO period.

Why This Decision Matters for Investors

For property investors, loan structure directly affects:

• Cash flow (monthly affordability)

• Tax deductibility (investment loan interest is generally deductible)

• Equity growth and portfolio expansion potential

• Overall investment return

A well-structured loan can mean the difference between owning one property and building a multi-property portfolio over the next decade.

How Interest-Only Loans Benefit Investors

Interest-only loans remain popular among Australian investors for one key reason: cash flow.

1. Improved Cash Flow and Flexibility

Because you’re only paying interest, monthly repayments can be 20 – 30 per cent lower than a comparable P&I loan.

That extra cash can be redirected toward:

• Saving for your next deposit,

• Covering renovation costs,

• Building a buffer for maintenance or vacancies, or

• Paying down non-deductible debt on your home loan.

For investors juggling multiple properties, this flexibility can make a big difference in managing their portfolio.

2. Tax Efficiency

Since interest on investment loans is tax-deductible, an IO structure can maximise your deductible expenses while freeing up cash flow elsewhere. Many investors use this structure to accelerate repayments on their owner-occupied (non-deductible) debt, which reduces overall tax drag.

3. Strategic Leverage

Maintaining a higher principal for longer means more leverage — which can be useful if property values are rising. In growth markets, this can boost your return on equity (ROE) and allow you to release more usable equity for your next purchase.

The Drawbacks of Interest-Only Loans

Despite the flexibility, there are trade-offs to consider.

1. You Don’t Build Equity as Quickly

Since you’re not repaying the principal, your loan balance doesn’t reduce during the IO period. This means your equity relies solely on property value growth.

If the market stagnates or dips, you could find yourself with little progress after several years.

2. Higher Long-Term Cost

IO loans often carry a slightly higher interest rate (usually 0.15 – 0.40 % p.a. more than equivalent P&I loans).Over the life of the loan, you’ll pay more total interest compared to repaying both principal and interest from the start.

3. Post-IO Repayment Shock

When the IO term ends, repayments revert to P&I over the remaining loan term. That means they increase significantly — sometimes by 30–40 %.If you haven’t planned ahead, this can cause serious cash-flow stress.

4. Stricter Lending Criteria

Since the banking royal commission and tighter APRA regulations, lenders assess your borrowing capacity as though you’re repaying principal from day one.That can reduce your maximum borrowing amount, even if you initially plan for IO repayments.

The Advantages of Principal & Interest Loans

1. Faster Equity Growth

Each payment chips away at your loan balance, steadily increasing your equity position. This can be a safer, more conservative approach — especially for investors with long-term “buy and hold” strategies.

2. Lower Interest Rates

In 2025, P&I investment loans are generally 0.2 – 0.5 % cheaper than IO loans. Over the first five years, this difference alone can save tens of thousands of dollars in interest.

3. Easier Loan Approvals

Lenders view P&I borrowers as lower risk. This can make approval smoother, especially for those with multiple loans or high debt-to-income ratios.

4. Reduced Risk in Flat Markets

If property prices plateau, you’re still improving your financial position because your debt is falling — something IO borrowers can’t claim during the same period.

The Downsides of P&I for Investors

• Reduced Cash Flow: Higher monthly repayments mean less spare cash for additional investments or emergency buffers.

• Lower Leverage: You’re paying down the loan, which can limit access to usable equity in the short term.

• Opportunity Cost: Extra repayments could be better directed to paying off non-deductible home debt first.

Comparing the Numbers

Here’s a simplified comparison for a $600,000 investment loan at 6.25 % p.a. over 30 years.

Loan Type	Monthly Repayment (approx.)	5-Year Total Paid	Principal Repaid
Interest-Only (first 5 years)	$3,125	$187,500	$0
Principal & Interest	$3,696	$221,760	~$63,000

Key takeaway: IO repayments save about $570 per month in the short term — valuable cash flow that can be strategically redirected. But the P&I borrower reduces their debt by around $63,000 over the same period.

What Lenders Are Doing in Late 2025

Australian lending policy continues to evolve. As of November 2025:

• Serviceability Buffers remain at 3 % above the actual rate, meaning a 6.25 % loan is assessed at 9.25 %.

• Debt-to-Income Ratios (DTI) are capped at 6 to 7 times gross income with most major banks.

• Interest-Only periods are typically capped at 5 years, though some non-bank lenders offer longer terms (up to 10 years).

• Refinancing demand has increased as investors look to restructure IO loans that are expiring from the 2019–2020 lending boom.

Non-bank lenders and smaller mutuals are currently more flexible on IO terms and valuation policy — a space where an experienced broker can add real value.

When Interest-Only Makes Sense

An IO loan can be the better choice when:

1. You prioritise cash flow — particularly in the early growth phase of your portfolio.

2. You plan to renovate or add value to a property before refinancing.

3. You want to maximise tax efficiency while paying down your owner-occupied loan faster.

4. You expect strong capital growth and want to leverage equity for further purchases.

5. You have a clear exit or refinance plan before the IO term ends.

In short: IO can be ideal for growth-oriented investors who use debt strategically and review their loans regularly.

When Principal & Interest Is the Better Option

Choose P&I when:

1. You’re in the consolidation phase — focusing on reducing overall debt.

2. You plan to hold long-term and value stability over short-term cash flow.

3. You have a positively-geared property that easily covers higher repayments.

4. You prefer simplicity and don’t want to worry about IO rollover or refinance timing.

5. You’re preparing for retirement and want to reduce liabilities progressively.

Combining the Two: Split-Loan Strategies

Many experienced investors use a hybrid approach — part IO and part P&I — to balance cash flow and debt reduction.

For example:

• 80 % IO for maximum deductible interest on the investment portion.

• 20 % P&I or offset account for controlled principal reduction.

A broker can structure this correctly across multiple properties and lenders, aligning it with your tax and long-term goals.

Tax and Accounting Considerations

The Australian Tax Office (ATO) allows interest deductions on loans used to purchase income-producing assets.However:

• If IO funds are used for personal purposes, that portion of interest isn’t deductible.

• Mixing personal and investment debt in the same account (such as redraw facilities) can create complex tax issues.

Always keep investment and personal loans separate, and work with both your broker and accountant to ensure your structure is tax-efficient and compliant.

Case Study: Two Investors, Two Strategies

Investor A – Interest-Only Strategy

Sarah bought an investment unit in Brisbane for $600,000 using an IO loan. Her repayments were about $3,100 per month, saving $600 compared to a P&I loan.She channelled those savings into paying down her home loan faster, reducing non-deductible debt by $35,000 over five years. When the property’s value rose to $720,000, she refinanced and used the equity to purchase her second investment.

Investor B – Principal & Interest Strategy

David purchased a similar property but opted for P&I repayments. After five years, he had repaid $65,000 of principal.While his cash flow was tighter, he felt more secure knowing his debt had reduced. When interest rates increased in 2025, his lower balance cushioned the impact.

Lesson: Both strategies can work — it depends on your priorities and overall financial position.

How to Decide Which Is Best for You

Ask yourself:

• Do I prioritise cash flow or debt reduction?

• What’s my investment timeframe — 5 years or 20?

• Do I plan to buy more properties soon?

• How would a rate rise affect my repayments?

• Have I accounted for tax and future refinancing costs?

A specialist investment mortgage broker can model each scenario using real-world numbers and lender policies — showing exactly how each option impacts your cash flow and future borrowing capacity.

Final Thoughts: Strategy Over Structure

There’s no universal answer to “Which loan type is best for investment property?”

• Interest-Only suits investors chasing cash-flow flexibility and aggressive growth.

• Principal & Interest suits investors seeking long-term stability and gradual wealth building.

The key is to choose a structure that supports your overall investment strategy, not just your current comfort level.

Remember: loan products and tax laws change, but sound strategy endures.

Ready to Review Your Loan Structure?

Whether you’re buying your first investment or managing several, getting your loan structure right can save you thousands — and set up your next purchase sooner.

Jack Brazel specialises in investment property finance, helping Australian investors find the right balance between cash flow, growth, and risk.

✅ Compare IO vs P&I options

✅ Model cash-flow scenarios

✅ Access lender policies across banks + non-banks